"Let me put it this way, if my brother wins the lottery, I'll be thrilled for him – after all, he's family – but when we go out for dinner, I'm not picking up his cheque," DALTON MCGUINTY
Ontario Premier Dalton McGuinty is dealing with an economic crisis. His province is spiraling towards recession and he is helpless to prevent it. His province is tied too closely to the American economy not to be sucked under in the vortex that is the collapsing American economy.
McGuinty has now reached into the sleazy play book of his predecessor, Mike Harris and has borrowed some rhetoric to take a shot at Newfoundland and Labrador. We want a free lunch he claims. While Ontario is dining on cat food we are eating Alberta Grade "A" beef.
He has a point, world oil prices and the demand for minerals has certainly greatly enhanced the coffers of our treasury to unimaginable levels. It is not the lottery though, it is a combination of careful, strategic development of non-renewable resources and record demands. I do not hear the workers in Sudbury complaining about the pay cheques they are bringing home through processing nickel from Newfoundland and Labrador. They are benefiting from the same lottery that we are.
After 59 years of trying to catch-up to the rest of Canada, we were well on our way before this latest energy crisis. We have 59 years of robbing Peter to pay Paul to catch up on. Roads to repair, schools and hospitals to build and a $12 Billion debt to tame. Ontario is becoming a have-not province because of economic levers beyond its control.
Ontario wants a fairer deal because equalization is not working for them. They do not understand why they continue to pay billions into the program at this point in time. I guess it is pointless to talk about the contribution of people, money and resources from our province to the Canadian federation.
The real danger here is the impact that not reaching a better political compromise will have on inter-provincial relationships and the long term viability of the Canadian federation. Perhaps it is time to for us to look at better political alliances, this east-west stuff has never done us much good anyways!
PS: McGuinty's comments can be found
here. Former PC Premier Mike Harris said "That's like somebody on welfare saying, `Well, I won the $1 million lottery and I have a $100,000 job, but I still want my welfare,". The current premiers comments are in quotations.